How do you find the posts worth commenting on?

Most posts in your feed do not need you. A few do. Here is the routine we use each morning to find them, and what to write.

Short answer

Keep a short list of people whose readers are your readers. Check their new posts once each morning. Comment only where you can add one thing the author did not say: a result from your own work, a counterexample, or a sharp question. Skip the rest.

Key points
  • A short list beats a busy feed.
  • Check once, early, while posts are new.
  • One real point in two sentences is enough.

Who should be on your list?

Pick people whose readers you want to reach, not only people you admire. A founder in your market. An analyst your buyers read. A peer one step ahead of you.

Keep the list short. About 25 people is enough. A longer list turns back into a feed.

When should you check?

Once a day, at the same time. In the morning, new posts have few comments, so a useful one is easy to see. Late in the day, the thread is full and your comment sinks.

How do you decide: comment or skip?

Use this table. If a post is not in the first two rows, skip it.

What you see What to do
A claim you have tested yourself Comment with your own result
A real question in your field Comment with an answer in two sentences
You agree and have nothing to add Skip. A like is enough
The post asks you to comment "yes" or "agree" Skip
A topic outside what you know or sell Skip

What should the comment say?

  1. Start with your point, not with praise.
  2. Add one thing the author did not say.
  3. Stop after two or three sentences.
  4. Ask a question only if you want the answer.
WeakGreat post, so true!
BetterWe tested this on our own pricing page. Showing the price brought fewer sales calls, but better ones.

How does Yaptivate help?

Yaptivate checks your list each morning. It puts the posts worth a comment at the top of Today and drafts a comment in your voice. You edit, approve and post.

Yaptivate does this for you every morning. Try it free for 7 days.

Try free for 7 days

Questions

How many comments a day is enough?

There is no right number. A few useful comments do more than many polite ones.

Should I comment on a competitor's post?

Only when you add something useful for their readers. Never pitch in someone else's thread.

Does this work on X and Reddit?

Yes. On Reddit, read the subreddit rules first and answer the question that was asked. Links to your own product often get removed.

How I wrote this. This guide comes from my own daily routine. It uses no outside data, so it shows no statistics.

Peter Balog is the founder of Yaptivate. He was a writer, an SEO and a fractional CMO for SaaS, PR and climate companies. peterbalog.com

Start showing up tomorrow morning.

Try free for 7 days
No charge for 7 days · Cancel any time