How do you find the posts worth commenting on?
Most posts in your feed do not need you. A few do. Here is the routine we use each morning to find them, and what to write.
Keep a short list of people whose readers are your readers. Check their new posts once each morning. Comment only where you can add one thing the author did not say: a result from your own work, a counterexample, or a sharp question. Skip the rest.
- A short list beats a busy feed.
- Check once, early, while posts are new.
- One real point in two sentences is enough.
Who should be on your list?
Pick people whose readers you want to reach, not only people you admire. A founder in your market. An analyst your buyers read. A peer one step ahead of you.
Keep the list short. About 25 people is enough. A longer list turns back into a feed.
When should you check?
Once a day, at the same time. In the morning, new posts have few comments, so a useful one is easy to see. Late in the day, the thread is full and your comment sinks.
How do you decide: comment or skip?
Use this table. If a post is not in the first two rows, skip it.
| What you see | What to do |
|---|---|
| A claim you have tested yourself | Comment with your own result |
| A real question in your field | Comment with an answer in two sentences |
| You agree and have nothing to add | Skip. A like is enough |
| The post asks you to comment "yes" or "agree" | Skip |
| A topic outside what you know or sell | Skip |
What should the comment say?
- Start with your point, not with praise.
- Add one thing the author did not say.
- Stop after two or three sentences.
- Ask a question only if you want the answer.
How does Yaptivate help?
Yaptivate checks your list each morning. It puts the posts worth a comment at the top of Today and drafts a comment in your voice. You edit, approve and post.
Yaptivate does this for you every morning. Try it free for 7 days.
Try free for 7 daysQuestions
How many comments a day is enough?
There is no right number. A few useful comments do more than many polite ones.
Should I comment on a competitor's post?
Only when you add something useful for their readers. Never pitch in someone else's thread.
Does this work on X and Reddit?
Yes. On Reddit, read the subreddit rules first and answer the question that was asked. Links to your own product often get removed.
How I wrote this. This guide comes from my own daily routine. It uses no outside data, so it shows no statistics.